Columbus City Council tables Fifth Street alley vacation

Courtesy-City of Columbus

COLUMBUS, Ind. — Following an extended debate over traffic, drainage, and procedural rules, the Columbus City Council voted to table a first-reading ordinance that would vacate a public north-south alley near Fifth Street.

Downtown property owners Jeff Baker and John Pickett requested that the alley running south from Fifth Street between two adjacent homes they own be vacated. Pickett told the council they planned to re-plat the properties together, gate the alley, and install gardens to eliminate cut-through school traffic and security issues.

Planning Director Jeff Bergman confirmed that local utility providers and city departments raised no initial objections during subdivision review. However, City Engineer Andrew Beckort stated during the City Council meeting that engineering's standard position is to retain functional alleys that provide block connectivity.

Council members Chris Bartels and Elaine Hilber said they were concerned about neighborhood flooding photos submitted by an adjacent resident, future downtown zoning density, and the absence of a formal Plan Commission review step in the current alley vacation process.

The initial motion to pass the ordinance failed 3–4. Kent Anderson, Jay Foist, and Tom Dell voted yes; Chris Bartels, Elaine Hilber, Jerone Wood, and Frank Miller voted no; Grace Kestler abstained due to proximity of family property; and Josh Burnett was absent.

The council then voted 5–2, with Foist and Dell opposed, to table the request so the Plan Commission can review alley vacation procedures in December.

More from Latest News